A publication of the National Electronics Manufacturing Center of Excellence November 2003

EMPF Director

Michael D. Frederickson
mfrederickson@aciusa.org


Sign up to receive email notifications of the newests issues of the EMPFasis!

Rapid Prototyping

In today's electronics industry, the demand has grown for products to be better, faster, and more user friendly. This has created a constant over turn of electronic devices causing manufactures to shorten their time-to-market window. OEMs (Original Equipment Manufactures) who performed their own preproduction and prototype assembling, no longer have the time and or equipment available to meet the market's needs. This started the creation of the contract manufacturing business where facilities were configured to handle quick turn assemblies known as rapid prototyping.

Typical prototype assembly work in electronics manufacturing usually means a small quantity of printed circuit boards manufactured over a programmed period of time. Rapid prototyping is a form of prototype assembly work that is performed in a short (1-5 day) time frame and typically costs more than that of standard prototype work.

Rapid Prototyping Obstacles:
The major cost and delivery time factors for any prototype assembly job are the issues that tend to develop prior to and during manufacturing. These designs can be loosely characterized as management driven or environment induced. For example, the assembly environment has a tendency to create restraints while the management drivers reflect the capability to overcome the difficulties imposed by the nature of the assembled products and the market. Some of these cost issues are easy to measure such as volume, cycle time, changeover time, and delivery performance. Other obstacles require extensive computing such as DPO (defects per opportunity) which take into account the number of components plus the number of solder joints per board. Many of the common problems are derived from non-measured issues such as gerber file inaccuracies and reflow profile setups. Table 1 is a list of some these potential pitfalls and cost drivers that are sometimes experienced before or during a prototype assembly build.

Issue Definition
Quality Indicator Factory wide defect per million opportunity or less satisfactory average first-pass yield multiplied by number of DPO's per square inch of board area.
Volume Total number of components or leads assembled per build
Cycle Time Number of days for assembly, test and rework, i.e. from kit release to the floor to shipping
Design Complexity The number of defects per opportunity which is the total number of components plus the total number of solder joints per square inch of board area.
Delivery Performance The percentage of completed boards delivered on time.
Management Complexity The number of unique boards assembled per year plus the annual number of design changes, plus the annual number of new design introductions.
Product Changeover The average time it takes to switch from one job to the next.
Equipment Limitations Board size constraints and component package types beyond equipment capabilities.
Reflow Profiles Not having a variety of reflow profiles that would accommodate different solder pastes and board sizes. This would create additional time to the setup.
Gerber Data Gerber data that doesn't include necessary information such as centroid component data, aperture lists, fiducial data, and board dimensions.
DFM - Design for Manufacturability Product that violates design specifications for such things as component to component tolerances, pad design and configuration, and minimal electrical clearances.

Conducting a Time Study:
There are several variables to consider when conducting a time study for any PCB assembly. It is important to first know the quantity of boards you are building. This will help determine what assembly level (ex. prototype, preproduction, small production, and large production) to use. It will also assist in defining the equipment level required for the build. The next factors to consider are the quantity and type of components being assembled. How many and whether the components are thru hole, surface mount, or both will dictate the type of equipment required as well as the process needed. Some other considerations include the initial setup time which is essential for performing tasks such as equipment programming and setup, process implementation, and board testing. Time spent refining these translates into costs known as the Non Recurring Engineering fees or NRE. The costs to perform the actual build are dictated by the quantity, level and design of the board. If the assembly is more prototype in nature, a large portion of the costs will be associated with labor. As the board and component quantities increase so does the need for more automated equipment. The cost of the machine, depreciation and maintenance create more of the expense offsetting the decrease in required labor.

Rapid Prototyping Setup Checklist

Initial Setup (common)
1. Determine Process (Manual or Automated Assembly)
2.Verify Gerber Files with PCB
3. Verify Bill of Material with PCB
4. Verify Paste Layer and Aperture List For Stencil.
5. Order Stencil and Confirm Ship Date
6. Verify Customer Supplied Material
7. Determine Solder Paste Chemistry

Automated Setup:
1. Setup Stencil Printer
2. Setup Pick & Place
3. Setup Axial Inserter
4. Setup DIP Inserter
5. Verify Oven Profile
6. Profile Oven (if required)
7. Setup Automated Optical Inspection (if available)
8. Setup Dispenser (if mixed technology)
9. Setup Wave Solder (if mixed technology)
10. Setup PCB Cleaner (if applicable)

Manual Setup:
1. Create Assembly Drawing Placement Key
2. Setup SMT components
3. Setup Thru-hole Components
4. Setup Hand Soldering Station
5. Setup Inspection Station

Time Study Example:
Table 2 (below) is an example of a mixed technology board in which a time study was conducted at different quantity levels using various operations. The board consists of 543 SMT and 320 thru hole components. The assembly levels are categorized based on quantity of boards. The calculated times are based on estimated labor hours and equipment capability.

Rapid Prototyping Setup Checklist:
Please use our helpful checklist to guide you in the initial prototype setup process. The list has been broken up into 3 sections that include the automated and manual requirements, along with items that are common to both.


Table 2 - Time vs. Volume

Board Qnty
10
100
1,000
100,000
Operation Rapid Prototype Preproduction (Semi Auto) Small Production (Auto) Large Production (Full Auto)
Side 1        
Stencil Print Manual Printer Semi Auto Printer Automated Printer Automated Printer
Time/brd (hrs) 0.1000 0.0500 0.0083 0.0083
*Solder Paste Inspection Manual Measuring System Semi Auto Measuring System In-line Paste Measuring System In-line Paste Measuring System
Time/brd (hrs) 1.0000 0.0200 0.0066 0.0066
SMT Placement Hand Placed Batch Pick & Place Med. Vol. In-line Pick & Place High Vol.In-line Pick & Place
Time/brd (hrs) 1.3080 0.3270 0.1090 0.0327
Reflow 3 Zone Reflow Oven 5 Zone Reflow Oven 7 Zone Reflow Oven 10 Zone Reflow Oven
Time/brd (hrs) 0.1000 0.0500 0.0100 0.0050
Post Reflow Inspection Visual Inspection Visual Inspection Bench Auto Optical Inspection In-line Auto Optical Inspection
Time/brd (hrs) 0.6500 0.6500 0.3270 0.1635
Side 2        
Dispensing Hand Dispense Batch Dispenser Med Vol. In-line Dispenser High Vol. In-line Dispenser
Time/brd (hrs) 0.8640 0.2160 0.0432 0.0216
SMT Placement Hand Placed Batch Pick & Place Med Vol. In-line Pick & Place High Vol.In-line Pick & Place
Time/brd (hrs) 0.8640 0.2160 0.0432 0.0216
Thru Hole (Axial) Hand Insert Batch Axial Inserter Med. Vol. In-line Axial Inserter High Vol. In-line Axial Inserter
Time/brd (hrs) 1.8000 0.5400 0.0900 0.0337
Thru Hole (DIP) Hand Insert Batch DIP Inserter Med. Vol. In-line DIP Inserter In-line DIP Inserter
Time/brd (hrs) 0.7000 0.1400 0.0700 0.0200
Soldering Hand Soldering Selective Soldering In-line Wave Solder In-line Wave Solder
Time/brd (hrs) 0.9440 0.0500 0.0100 0.0100
Cleaning Hand Clean Batch Cleaner In-line Cleaner In-line Cleaner
Time/brd (hrs) 0.0400 0.0200 0.0100 0.0100
Testing Bench Functional Test Bench Fuctional Test Bench Functional Automated Test In-line Funtional Automated Test
Time/brd (hrs) 0.2000 0.2000 0.0200 0.0066
         
         
Total Time/brd (hrs) 8.5700 2.4790 0.7473 0.3396



[site map]